Connect with us

BUSINESS

Elmer W. Davis Pays $16,782 After Misconduct Defense Fails

Elmer W. Davis lost a 40-foot hoist-area case after the misconduct defense that vacated a 2021 citation failed, and the penalty is $16,782.

Published

on

A federal safety judge ordered Elmer W. Davis Inc. to pay $16,782 for two serious violations on a four-story Newark roof. The April 4, 2022 job was a flat-roof replacement at the Village of Newark municipal building.

Nobody fell. The worker who stepped through a guardrail gap to signal a crane stood about 40 feet above the pavement without personal fall protection, and the company had already been in front of the same judge on a fall case it won.

A Crane Signaler Stood Outside the Guardrail

Elmer W. Davis, a Rochester commercial roofing contractor with more than 250 employees, sent an 11-person crew to 100 E. Miller Street to replace the flat roof of the village municipal building. The main roof ran about 60 by 100 feet. The next level down was the ground, about 40 feet below. A parapet around the edge stood about 28 inches high and 15 inches wide.

Another company crew had already clamped guardrails to most of that parapet. Along the west edge, though, three freestanding modular rails sat in 100-pound baseplates. The posts of adjacent rails shared a plate, leaving a gap of about seven inches at the base and a little more at the top. With the plates pushed as close as they would go, the top rails still sat at least 27 inches in from the outer parapet edge.

A crane in the west parking lot was hoisting roofing materials. The operator could not see the landing zone. Gabriel Calas-Alvarez, an Elmer W. Davis employee, gave hand signals from the roof. Around 2 p.m. he stepped through that seven-inch gap, into the one-foot strip between the modular rail and the parapet, and stood there without a personal fall-protection system.

A compliance officer from OSHA’s Syracuse office was driving past, saw a worker at the roof edge, and stopped. He watched from a parking lot about 200 feet away, then from a second lot about 500 feet away. Calas-Alvarez stayed beyond the rails for at least the three minutes the officer watched from the street. After the load landed, he slid back through the gap.

The installation foreman, a 15-year company employee and a foreman for five years, was working the same west edge, less than 100 feet south. He described himself as a working foreman. Four-foot bundles of insulation board sat as close as 10 feet from that edge. Judge William S. Coleman found those stacks were not high enough to block a sightline. The foreman swore he did not see the signaler outside the rail. Coleman wrote that, with reasonable diligence, he should have known.

The officer later went onto the roof after getting authorization to inspect. He found three other workers on an 8-by-10-foot bulkhead roof about 10 feet above the main roof, and a portable ladder that did not extend three feet above the landing.

Elmer W. Davis OSHA Penalty for the Newark Roof

OSHA issued three serious citations under the construction standards in 29 C.F.R. Part 1926 and proposed $26,106. The company contested. The case went to the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission under simplified proceedings. Coleman held a two-day hearing in Rochester on March 30 and 31, 2023. Post-hearing briefs closed on August 18, 2023.

His written findings in docket 22-1210, dated September 30, 2024, with a clerical errata on October 11, affirmed two items and vacated one. The assessed total was $16,782. The U.S. Department of Labor, in an October 24, 2024 release, said the judge found knowledge because the fall-protection breach was readily visible to the foreman and because the company had failed to carry out its safety program. The Labor Department described the upheld counts as two serious fall protection and ladder violations.

THE THREE NEWARK CITATIONS

Item Standard Allegation Outcome
1 § 1926.501(b)(3) Hoist-area signaler without required fall protection Affirmed
2 § 1926.501(b)(10) Bulkhead low-slope roofing without a compliant safety-monitoring system Vacated
3 § 1926.1053(b)(1) Ladder side rails short of 3 feet above the landing Affirmed
Total – Proposed $26,106 for three items Assessed $16,782

Coleman also walked through OSHA’s own penalty math and found two offsetting mistakes. The agency had cut 10% for company size after treating Elmer W. Davis as if it had fewer than 250 employees; the record showed more than 250, so that cut should not have applied. It had also skipped a 10% cut for history of violations that, under the agency’s own protocol, should have applied. The two errors canceled. He adopted the secretary’s treatment of size, history, and good faith as presented at the hearing and assessed $16,782.

The company argued the inspection violated the Fourth Amendment. Coleman held that Elmer W. Davis had no reasonable expectation of privacy on a rooftop it did not own, and that the officer acted reasonably. Julie C. Pittman and David J. Rutenberg of the Labor Department’s New York solicitor’s office tried the case. Michael Rubin of Ogletree Deakins appeared for the company.

As the U.S. Department of Labor’s vigorous litigation showed, and the judge appropriately held, Elmer W. Davis Inc. failed to protect employees from fall hazards and cannot claim permanent and complete freedom to commit violations.

Jeffrey S. Rogoff, Regional Solicitor of Labor, U.S. Department of Labor

The company filed a petition on October 18, 2024. The decision was set to become a Commission order on October 30 unless a member directed review. On November 15, 2024, the Commission posted it as a final order.

Why the 2021 Misconduct Defense Did Not Travel

Elmer W. Davis asked Coleman to treat its unforeseeable-employee-misconduct defense as already decided. About a year before the Newark job, the same judge had vacated a fall-protection citation against the same company on that defense. The company said the secretary should be collaterally estopped from fighting it again.

Coleman said the elements of collateral estoppel were not there. He then tried the defense on the Newark facts and found the company had not proved it.

The earlier case, docket 21-1021, started on April 30, 2021. OSHA’s officer, again driving past a job, saw two Elmer W. Davis employees on the low-slope roof of a one-story commercial building in Rochester, about 15 feet up, on a roof less than 50 feet wide. The fall-protection rule for that kind of roof allowed a safety-monitoring system as the only protection. The officer photographed the pair for about 10 minutes, then had them come down. The company showed a work rule, training, inspections, and discipline. Coleman vacated the citation. The Commission posted that decision as a final order on March 24, 2023, a few days before the Newark hearing opened in the same city.

On the Newark roof the knowledge theory was different. The secretary proved the foreman had constructive knowledge of the hoist-area breach, imputable to the company, and also that the safety program was inadequate. Unpreventable employee misconduct was not a free pass from the last case, and it was not proved on this one.

Fourteen Feet Through a Warehouse Roof

A third Commission matter sits behind both of those drive-by inspections. On September 17, 2020, an Elmer W. Davis crew began tearing off a warehouse roof. After they cut through a five-inch membrane, an unsafe depression in the deck showed up. The project superintendent had it covered with a 4-by-8-foot sheet of plywood. Someone later moved the sheet. An employee stepped on the open depression, the deck gave way, and he fell fourteen feet through the warehouse roof to the floor. He was hospitalized for serious injuries.

Tim Crumb, the company’s corporate safety director, appeared in that case. Coleman affirmed a serious citation under the rule that an employer must determine whether walking surfaces will hold workers. The Commission posted the decision as a final order on August 25, 2023, five months after the 2021 citation was wiped out and five months after the Newark hearing.

THREE ELMER W. DAVIS FALL DOCKETS

  1. September 17, 2020: A worker falls 14 feet through a warehouse roof deck and is hospitalized; the citation is later affirmed.
  2. April 30, 2021: OSHA photographs two roofers on a 15-foot Rochester roof; the citation is vacated on employee misconduct and becomes a final order on March 24, 2023.
  3. April 4, 2022: OSHA watches a crane signaler outside the guardrail on the Newark municipal roof; two citations are affirmed and $16,782 is assessed in a September 30, 2024 decision that becomes a final order on November 15, 2024.

The Newark inspection recorded a hazard, not an injury. The warehouse job is the one in this set where a worker hit the floor. Jeffrey Prebish, OSHA’s Syracuse area director, said falls from roofs and other elevations are the leading cause of death in construction, “needlessly killing hundreds of workers each year and leaving many more with permanent and often disabling injuries,” and that Elmer W. Davis “violated mandatory federal safety regulations and put workers in danger.”

Roofing Contractors Logged 96 Fatal Falls in 2024

The Bureau of Labor Statistics Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries for 2024 put numbers under that warning. Roofing remains among the deadliest trades in the country, and falls are how most of those deaths happen.

FALL DEATHS IN 2024

  • 104 roofers: Deaths in the roofer occupation, at a rate of 48.7 per 100,000 full-time workers, 14.8 times the all-worker rate of 3.3.
  • 96 of 120: Deaths at roofing contractors (the industry count, which includes other job titles on those payrolls) caused by falls, slips, or trips, or 80%.
  • 389 construction deaths: Falls, slips, and trips out of 1,034 private construction fatalities, or 37.6%.
  • 5,070 U.S. deaths: All fatal work injuries nationwide, with construction’s rate at 9.2 per 100,000.

Those figures are why a 40-foot unprotected hoist area is classified as a serious violation: death or grave harm could follow, even when a given inspection ends with everyone walking off the roof. They are also why $16,782 lands as a small number next to the harm the rule is written to stop.

OSHA’s inflation-adjusted civil penalties in calendar 2024 topped out at $16,131 for a serious violation. After January 15, 2025, the published maximum of $16,550 per serious violation applies, with willful or repeated violations listed at $165,514. The Newark total of $16,782 is two serious items, not one citation at the cap, and it was built from the 2022 proposal after contest, hearing, and the offsetting size and history adjustments Coleman described. For crews that work at height, the agency also publishes OSHA stop-falls training materials in English and Spanish, plus a separate guide on protecting roofing workers.

Willful and repeat cases in the same trade have drawn proposed bills in the hundreds of thousands of dollars when OSHA has stacked those classifications. The Newark citations were serious, not willful or repeat. The expected cost of a 40-foot edge case that a 250-person contractor fights for two and a half years, from inspection to written decision, is the $16,782 that is now a final order.

The Company Calls Its Safety Program Exemplary

Elmer W. Davis, founded in 1936, rejected Coleman’s findings. In a statement it said no employees fell or were injured in the Newark inspection and that the Labor Department had mischaracterized the matter. It also put a number on its inspection history.

WHAT THE COMPANY COUNTED

  • Thirteen inspections: The company said OSHA had inspected it 13 times since 2013.
  • Eleven with no citations: It said 11 of those 13 found full compliance and produced no citations.
  • One win at trial: It said one remaining cited matter was contested, tried, and beaten, a description that matches the vacated 2021 Rochester roof case.
  • This case as the leftover: It treated the Newark docket as the last of the 13, and did not mention the 2020 warehouse fall in that tally.

Commission records are public on all three of those dockets. The 2021 win is real. So is the 2020 hospitalization and the affirmed citation that followed. So is the Newark order. The inspection-count statement and the docket are not the same list.

In view of its past compliance, EWD does not believe that the matter addressed in the news release provides an accurate reflection of its health and safety plan and efforts, much less its prior performance.

Elmer W. Davis Inc., company statement

The company said it “must take issue with any suggestion that its safety and health program is anything but comprehensive, effective, and exemplary,” and that it invests significant resources to protect employees. Coleman’s Newark decision found the opposite on that job: constructive knowledge through the foreman, and a safety program that had not been carried out well enough to stop a signaler from standing outside the rail on a 40-foot roof.

The Commission posted the Newark decision as a final order on November 15, 2024. Elmer W. Davis still does low-slope commercial roofing across western and central New York and into Pennsylvania.

Harry is the editor of IAQABA, an independent publication he owns and runs. A decade in journalism, beginning as a reporter and now as the editor of his own titles, has left him with a clear test for what deserves a story: it has to change what a reader knows or decides, and it has to rest on something he can point to. That rules out recycled press releases, forecasts with no data behind them and rumours that no document supports. It leaves room for a great deal, and the site covers news, business, science and technology alongside sports, entertainment and lifestyle, with travel, auto and gaming given the same standard rather than lighter treatment. Sources are primary wherever possible: the regulator's filing, the company's own statement, the transcript, the dataset, or the product on Harry's desk. Figures are checked before they are published and rechecked if a reader questions them. Mistakes are corrected under a published policy. Readers across the world can reach him directly at support@iaqaba.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending