Connect with us

BUSINESS

White House Weighs a 401(k) Safe Harbor That Includes Crypto

A Labor Department safe harbor under White House review would cover private equity and crypto in 401(k)s, without forcing any plan to offer Bitcoin.

Published

on

The White House began reviewing a Labor Department final rule on November 5 that would give 401(k) fiduciaries a legal safe harbor for crypto and other alternative assets. The Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs logged the package as economically significant, with no legal deadline. The rule is not in force, and its final text is still unpublished.

Nothing in the filing orders an employer to put Bitcoin on a menu. The live product is a process shield for the people who build those menus, covering private equity, real estate, digital-asset funds and other alternatives inside the country’s largest workplace savings pool.

Labor’s Final Alternatives Rule Reaches the White House

OIRA’s docket lists the measure as “Fiduciary Duties In Selecting Designated Investment Alternatives,” RIN 1210-AC38, sent by the Employee Benefits Security Administration. The same office cleared a proposed version after receiving it on January 13, 2026, and closing that pass on March 24. Labor issued the proposal on March 30 and published it the next day.

The Insured Retirement Institute, a trade group for annuity and retirement firms, has said reviews of this kind often take 60 to 90 days, with an effective date toward the end of the first quarter of 2027. That is an industry clock, not a statutory one. Until OIRA finishes and Labor prints a final rule, plan menus do not change.

HOW THE RULE GOT TO OIRA

  1. March 10, 2022: Labor tells 401(k) fiduciaries to use “extreme care” before adding cryptocurrency to a plan menu.
  2. May 28, 2025: The department rescinded its 2022 cryptocurrency warning and restored a neutral stance.
  3. August 7, 2025: President Donald Trump signs the August 2025 alternative-assets executive order, numbered 14330, and gives Labor 180 days to rewrite the guidance.
  4. March 31, 2026: Labor’s March 31 proposed regulation appears in the Federal Register at 91 FR 16088, with comments due June 1.
  5. November 5, 2026: The final rule arrives at OIRA for the last White House check before publication.

Executive Order 14330 says more than 90 million Americans sit in employer-sponsored defined-contribution plans, and that most of them have no way into alternative assets. Labor’s March 30 press release used the same 90 million figure when it rolled out the proposal. A crypto market-structure bill already stalled in the House, which is one reason this retirement rule has become the live federal path for digital assets into workplace plans.

Six Factors and a Presumption of Prudence

The proposal does not bless any asset class. It builds a checklist. A fiduciary who follows it, Labor wrote, is presumed to have met the prudence duty in section 404(a)(1)(B) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 and is “entitled to significant deference.”

That presumption is the mechanism. ERISA already lets a loyal, careful fiduciary consider almost any investment. What has kept private funds and crypto vehicles off most 401(k) menus is the fear of a later lawsuit that second-guesses the choice. The order told Labor to “prioritize actions that may curb ERISA litigation.” The proposed harbor is how the department answered.

THE SIX PRUDENCE FACTORS

  • Performance: Compare a reasonable number of similar options and judge risk-adjusted expected returns, net of fees, over a suitable horizon.
  • Fees: Decide that costs are appropriate given those returns and any other value the option brings to the plan.
  • Liquidity: Weigh how easily the holding can be sold or redeemed against the plan’s needs.
  • Valuation: Confirm the option can be valued in a timely and accurate way for the plan.
  • Benchmarking: Identify a meaningful benchmark and compare net risk-adjusted expected returns against it.
  • Complexity: Account for how hard the product is for the fiduciary, and for participants, to understand.

The six items are “non-exhaustive.” Labor said a fiduciary must consider them “objectively, thoroughly, and analytically” when they apply. Deputy Secretary of Labor Keith Sonderling put the department’s claim in one line when the proposal went out.

The department’s days of picking winners and losers are over. Our rule clearly spells out that managers must evaluate any and all potential product offerings by following a prudent process.

Keith Sonderling, Deputy Secretary of Labor, March 30, 2026 department statement

Crypto never needed a special permission slip. Direct holdings and funds tied to digital assets were not banned under ERISA. The 2022 “extreme care” memo was the barrier that mattered, because it signaled that Labor might later second-guess the fiduciary. Taking that memo off the books in May 2025, then writing a process harbor, is the actual policy change.

Private Funds Want a Pipe Into $10.8 Trillion

The Investment Company Institute put U.S. retirement assets at $51.2 trillion on June 30, 2026, up 7.9 percent from March, and equal to 33 percent of household financial assets. Inside that pile, Americans held $10.8 trillion in 401(k) plans. Defined-contribution plans as a group held $15.0 trillion. Individual retirement accounts held $19.9 trillion.

U.S. RETIREMENT ASSETS ON JUNE 30, 2026

Bucket Assets
Individual retirement accounts $19.9 trillion
401(k) plans $10.8 trillion
403(b) plans $1.6 trillion
Federal Thrift Savings Plan $1.2 trillion
Other private-sector defined contribution $920 billion
457 plans $585 billion
Government defined benefit $10.4 trillion
Private-sector defined benefit $3.2 trillion
Annuity reserves outside retirement accounts $2.7 trillion
Total retirement assets $51.2 trillion

Mutual funds held $6.2 trillion, or 58 percent, of 401(k) assets, with $3.7 trillion in equity funds and $1.7 trillion in hybrid funds, a group that includes target-date strategies. That is the pipe private-fund sponsors have wanted for years: automatic payroll contributions, long holding periods, and a buyer that does not sell in a panic the way a hedge-fund client might.

A 2 percent crypto sleeve on the entire $10.8 trillion 401(k) pool would be $216 billion. That arithmetic only works if every plan and every saver takes the sleeve, which they will not. Private equity and private credit are the larger prize, because they can be folded into the default funds most workers already hold, at weights far above a novelty crypto line.

Who Gets Cover When a Worker Sues

The overlooked parties are not retail Bitcoin holders. They are the plan sponsor who picks the menu, the recordkeeper who has to operationalize an illiquid sleeve, the alternative-asset manager who wants a new distribution channel, and the fiduciary-liability insurers who pay when those choices get sued.

Assistant Secretary Daniel Aronowitz signed the proposal. Before he ran EBSA, he founded Encore Fiduciary, formerly Euclid Fiduciary, in 2011, a firm that sells liability coverage to the same plan sponsors this rule is written to protect. Ranking Member Maxine Waters of the House Financial Services Committee made that history the core of her attack.

The proposal would create a so-called safe harbor that encourages the fiduciaries of 401(k) and other participant-directed retirement plans to place private equity, private credit, real estate, commodities, digital assets, and other illiquid, opaque, and high-cost “alternative” investments on the menus that tens of millions of American workers rely on to build a secure retirement.

Rep. Maxine Waters, Ranking Member, House Financial Services Committee, June 25, 2026 letter

Waters’s June comment letter said the proposal relies on Encore Fiduciary’s work for litigation-cost figures, cites Aronowitz’s old “Fid Guru Blog,” and forecasts “a stabilization or reduction of premiums” in the fiduciary-insurance market. She wrote that Labor had not disclosed whether he fully divested or received an ethics waiver, and she asked the department to withdraw the rule. The department has not answered that ethics demand in public.

Secretary of Labor Lori Chavez-DeRemer, when the 2022 crypto memo came off the books, said the prior administration “made a choice to put their thumb on the scale” and that investment decisions “should be made by fiduciaries, not D.C. bureaucrats.” The harbor tries to make that claim stick in court. If it holds, the people who used to get sued for adding an unusual fund get a documented process to point to. If it fails, the lawsuits the order wanted to curb come back, and the insurance market Aronowitz used to underwrite stays in the same fight.

Target-Date Funds Would Carry the First Wave

Labor did not confine the proposal to the “asset allocation fund” vehicle named in the executive order. The department said it would apply the same prudence process to any designated investment alternative on a participant-directed menu. In practice, the first money is still likely to move the way most 401(k) money already moves: inside target-date funds that workers get as a default.

LABOR’S OWN FLOW ESTIMATE

  • $178 billion a year: Sum the proposal’s impact analysis says would flow into target-date funds that hold alternative investments.
  • 4.5 million participants: Workers attached to those estimated flows each year.
  • 47,333 plans: Plans the department said would be affected annually, after some sponsors add more than one series.

Those figures are Labor’s own model from the March proposal, built from large-plan data and then stretched to the whole market. They are not a forecast of Bitcoin buying. They describe sleeves inside the hybrid funds that already hold $1.7 trillion of 401(k) money. A worker who never ticks a crypto box can still pick up private equity, private credit or a digital-asset sleeve if that is how the default fund is built.

Plan managers still decide. Regulatory clearance, if it comes, only changes the legal climate around that decision. Recordkeepers have to be able to value the sleeve, handle redemptions, and explain it on a quarterly statement. Until those products exist in a form a fiduciary will sign, the harbor is a shield without a new fund behind it.

The Case Against Parking Nest Eggs in Private Funds

The order’s own definition of “alternative assets” shows why crypto is the loud wrapping and not the whole package.

WHAT EXECUTIVE ORDER 14330 CALLS ALTERNATIVE ASSETS

Category How the order defines it
Private market investments Equity, debt, or other instruments not traded on public exchanges, including deals where managers take an active role
Real estate Direct and indirect interests, including debt secured by real estate
Digital assets Holdings in actively managed vehicles that invest in digital assets
Commodities Direct and indirect investments
Infrastructure Interests in projects that finance infrastructure development
Lifetime income Strategies that include longevity risk-sharing pools

Digital assets sit in slot three, and even there the order points to managed vehicles, not a spot-Bitcoin ticker a worker picks at lunch. AARP, in a June 1 comment, did not demand a full withdrawal. It asked Labor to keep long-standing participant protections and warned that private credit and private equity funds often cap withdrawals. Better Markets told the department it lacked authority to thin out workers’ access to the courts. Eileen Appelbaum, a longtime private-equity researcher, called the six factors too vague to paper over what she called imprudent products.

WHERE THE FIGHT ACTUALLY SITS

  • Liquidity mismatch: A 401(k) lets a worker take a loan or a cash-out; many private funds do not.
  • Fee drag: Alternative products often charge more than the index funds that now dominate menus.
  • Valuation lag: Private holdings are priced on a schedule, not on a public tape, which complicates daily account values.
  • Default-fund risk: A sleeve inside a target-date fund can reach people who never chose the underlying assets.

Supporters answer with a different comparison. Public pension plans have held private equity and real estate for years, they say, while 401(k) savers were left in public stocks and bonds because lawyers made the alternatives too expensive to defend. National Taxpayers Union backed the proposal as an asset-class-neutral process. The harbor tries to split that fight by making the process the defense, rather than the asset.

OIRA can send the package back, sit on it, or clear it. Labor then has to publish a final rule and name an effective date. After that, the choice still belongs to employers and the fiduciaries they hire. The White House review is a gate, not a product launch, and the people with the most money on the table are the ones who build the menus, sell the private funds, and write the insurance around the lawsuits that used to stop both.

Disclaimer: This article is news reporting and analysis of a Labor Department rulemaking and a White House review. It is for information only and is not investment, tax, legal or retirement-planning advice. It does not recommend buying, holding or avoiding cryptocurrency, private equity, real estate funds or any 401(k) option, and it does not tell plan sponsors how to meet their duties under ERISA. Readers who may be affected should consult a qualified fiduciary, ERISA counsel, tax professional or financial adviser before making account or plan-menu decisions. Figures, docket statuses and the unpublished final text reflect the official and industry sources cited as of the dates given in the piece and can change when OIRA completes review or Labor publishes a final rule.

Harry is the editor of IAQABA, an independent publication he owns and runs. A decade in journalism, beginning as a reporter and now as the editor of his own titles, has left him with a clear test for what deserves a story: it has to change what a reader knows or decides, and it has to rest on something he can point to. That rules out recycled press releases, forecasts with no data behind them and rumours that no document supports. It leaves room for a great deal, and the site covers news, business, science and technology alongside sports, entertainment and lifestyle, with travel, auto and gaming given the same standard rather than lighter treatment. Sources are primary wherever possible: the regulator's filing, the company's own statement, the transcript, the dataset, or the product on Harry's desk. Figures are checked before they are published and rechecked if a reader questions them. Mistakes are corrected under a published policy. Readers across the world can reach him directly at support@iaqaba.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending