Connect with us

BUSINESS

France’s Interest Bill Overtakes School Spending Before 2027

France’s 2027 state interest bill of €72.9 billion overtakes the school budget as 10-year yields near 5% and parliament rejects the cuts.

Published

on

France’s state interest bill is set at €72.9 billion for 2027, more than the school budget once civil-service pensions are set aside. That gap is already visible in classrooms. High schools have been blockaded since September, and the 10-year bond yield touched 5.14% on 22 October, a level last printed in July 2002.

Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu’s minority government still has no 2027 budget. Unions called the country’s 5.8 million public-sector workers to strike on 17 November, five months before a presidential first round on 18 April 2027.

France’s Interest Bill Overtakes School Spending

The 2027 draft puts the state’s debt charge at €72.9 billion, up from €62.6 billion in 2026, a rise of €10.3 billion in one year. The school-education mission, with civil-service pensions taken out so the lines can be compared, goes from €64.4 billion to €65.5 billion, a rise of €1.1 billion. Defence, on the same basis, goes from €57.0 billion to €63.4 billion.

THE 2027 STATE BUDGET, PENSIONS SET ASIDE

Budget line 2026 (bn euros) 2027 (bn euros) Change
State debt interest 62.6 72.9 +10.3
School education 64.4 65.5 +1.1
Defence 57.0 63.4 +6.4

Creditors, on that arithmetic, take a larger cheque than the school mission. Across all public administrations, interest is booked at €79.2 billion in 2026 and €91.2 billion in 2027, then €103.7 billion in 2028 and €125.8 billion in 2030, according to figures the budget rapporteur Philippe Juvin drew from Bercy. Finance Minister Roland Lescure told the Senate finance committee that the 2027 interest bill would reach 91 billion euros and might hit 100 billion before 2030.

Insee, the national statistics office, put public debt of €3,595.5 billion at the end of June, or 119.0% of GDP, after 117.5% in the first quarter and 115.7% at the end of 2025. The government still projects 119.3% by the end of 2026 and 121.7% in 2027, even if the 5.0% deficit target is met. The same squeeze has already shown up in China’s local-government interest bill, which has climbed to 19.2% of spending. France’s version arrives as a classroom fight.

Blocked Lycées and a Fourth Frozen Pay Year

The movement began in mid-September in poorer suburbs of Paris and spread through lycées, France’s high schools. Students demanded replacements for missing teachers, repairs to worn buildings, and less crowded rooms. Lecornu at one point paused classes for a week and said burning down a high school does not improve the state of high school buildings. Teachers’ unions later accused the government of letting the blockades turn dangerous.

THE SCHOOL CRISIS IN FIGURES

  • Injuries: More than 360 schoolchildren and 245 staff have been hurt since the protests began.
  • Principals: At least 50 headteachers have asked to leave their posts.
  • Lost hours: Exam-year pupils have missed up to 150 hours of teaching where schools were barricaded or shut.
  • The offer: The government put €4 billion of cheap loans on school repairs, 15,000 extra university seats for 2027-28, and 3,303 extra education posts in 2027, down from 5,940 in 2026.
  • Pay: The draft rules out a general public-sector rise for a fourth year; unions put the loss of purchasing power since 2017 at 16%.

Student unions called that package too thin. The pay freeze is the hinge with the bond market. Lecornu’s draft needs the freeze, smaller rises in some pensions and welfare, a nominal freeze of central spending outside defence, and tighter local-government limits to land a €54 billion effort, of which €43 billion is new. Without it, Bercy says the 2027 deficit would near 6.5% of GDP rather than the 5.0% target. On 17 November, after talks with the prime minister failed to produce an across-the-board rise, unions called those 5.8 million public workers out again.

France Now Pays More Than Italy to Borrow

Investors have not priced a missed payment. They have priced a French premium. On 22 October the 10-year Obligation assimilable du Trésor, the OAT, touched 5.14%, and the gap over German Bunds reached its widest since November 2011. Germany’s 10-year yield was 3.38% in that session. By 16 November the French 10-year was near 4.95% and the gap over Germany was 156 basis points. Italian 10-year yields sat lower, reversing the ranking of the last euro-area debt crisis, when Rome was the risk and Paris was the refuge.

FRENCH BORROWING COSTS THIS AUTUMN

  • 22 October high: 5.14% on the 10-year, the most since July 2002.
  • Gap over Germany: the widest since November 2011.
  • Mid-November: near 4.95%, above Italian 10-year yields.
  • Since the Hormuz shock: OATs up about 150 basis points, against about 132 for Italy, 115 for the United States, and 83 for Germany, per Allianz economists Ludovic Subran, Ana Boata, Maxime Darmet and Patrick Krizan.

Ulrich Stephan and Wolf Kisker at Deutsche Bank’s CIO desk wrote that the 100-basis-point gap over Bunds was breached on 18 September for the first time since 2012, after the 2026 deficit was revised to 5.4% of GDP from a 5.0% plan and growth was cut to 0.5%. The 2025 deficit was 5.1%, and 2024 was 5.8%. Four years above 5% is the record investors are compounding into the coupon.

Moody’s kept France at Aa3 with a negative outlook on 23 October. S&P and Fitch rate the country A+. The IMF’s October maps show a primary deficit of 2.9% of GDP for 2026, meaning the state is still borrowing before it pays a euro of interest. Italy, with heavier debt relative to output, is on course for a primary surplus of 1.0%, the only G7 country in that position.

Cheap Coupons From the 2010s Come Due Next Year

Agence France Trésor, the state’s debt office, listed negotiable government debt of €2,921 billion on 30 September, with an average life of 8 years and 139 days. Medium- and long-term paper had a life of 9 years and 8 days. That long book is why a 5.14% print does not hit the budget in one season. It is also why the bill keeps climbing as cheap bonds from the low-rate years are replaced.

Only a small share of the negotiable book is short-term paper that reprices at once. The rest rolls off on a lag, so 2027 is when a large block of low-coupon bonds must be refinanced into a market that now wants something close to 5% for 10 years. Debt-servicing costs alone are expected to rise by about €10 billion next year, matching the €10.3 billion step-up in the state interest line. Planet Money hosts Jeff Guo and Erika Beras put the wider point in one sentence: “As interest rates climb, that borrowing spree might have to come to an end.”

On 16 November the Treasury still sold €7.171 billion of short-term bills, with cover ratios between 2.23 and 2.79 and average rates from 2.708% to 3.389%. Lenders are bidding. They are charging more for the long end, and they are charging France more than they charge Italy.

Non-Residents Hold Most of the Long Bonds

Banque de France figures show non-residents held 58.4% of long-term general-government securities at the end of June, up from 55.9% at the end of March. That is the opposite of the old euro-crisis doom loop, in which Italian and Spanish banks were stuffed with their own governments’ paper. BNP Paribas, Société Générale and Crédit Agricole together hold about €54 billion of French sovereign debt, a modest stock for banks of that size, and Emmanuelle Assouan, who heads the ACPR supervisor, has said that mix does not pose a stability risk even as yields jump.

The exposure sits abroad. Allianz’s note says foreign banks and non-banks hold 36% of OATs, and Japanese investors about 5%, or €137 billion. Those accounts can sell. The Eurosystem is no longer the silent buyer: maturing bonds bought under older purchase programmes are not being replaced, so Paris has to clear a heavy issuance calendar in public markets. The 2027 draft sets a €340 billion ceiling on debt issuance, after €310 billion in 2026.

French bank credit default swaps have widened with the sovereign, and additional-tier-1 notes have been the weakest link, because investors still treat the state’s credit as the floor under the banks. The banks are not the first loser. The first loser is the budget line that does not have a coupon attached to it.

The Assembly Voted the Budget Down 458 to None

Lecornu replaced François Bayrou after parliament brought that government down, and he used Article 49.3 of the constitution to force through the 2026 budget. He does not have a majority for 2027. On 4 November the National Assembly rejected the revenue half of the bill by 458 to none, with two abstentions, which under French budget rules sank the whole text at first reading.

THE BUDGET CALENDAR

  1. July 2024: The European Union places France under an excessive-deficit procedure and later caps EU-defined net spending growth at 1.2% a year from 2026 to 2028, with the deficit to be corrected by 2029.
  2. 1 October 2026: The government presents a 2027 budget aiming for a 5.0% deficit through a €54 billion effort.
  3. 22 October 2026: The 10-year yield touches 5.14% the day before Moody’s review.
  4. 4 November 2026: The Assembly rejects the bill 458 to none.
  5. 5 November 2026: A nationwide strike draws 575,000 people on the Interior Ministry count and 1.6 million on the CGT union count.
  6. 17 November 2026: Public-sector unions strike again after pay talks fail.
  7. 20 November 2026: The Senate begins floor debate on the original draft, with a vote listed for 9 December.

Options after that include a second Assembly reading, a joint committee, another 49.3, or ordinances that would only be possible later in December. Each path runs into the same street. Public-accounts minister David Amiel said the work is large because the alternative is worse.

If we do nothing, the deficit will spiral out of control in 2027.

David Amiel, public accounts minister, on franceinfo radio

Even the 5.0% target does not stop the debt ratio from rising. Allianz puts the deficit that would stabilise the ratio at 2.7% of GDP, which would take more than €80 billion of savings, plus €15 billion to €20 billion a year to stop social spending and interest from opening the gap again. The €54 billion package is a first cut at 5%, not a path off the rise.

What a Near-5 Percent Yield Means for 2027

The presidential first round is on 18 April 2027, with a second round on 2 May. Macron cannot stand again. Campaigns that promise tax cuts or new spending will be priced against a 10-year yield that has already seen 5.14% and was still near 4.95% in mid-November. Allianz’s baseline is a president short of a majority who seeks alliances, with the 2028 deficit still near 4.9% and OAT spreads above 100 basis points. Their stress case, with unfunded giveaways, puts spreads above 200 basis points. Only then, in their view, would the European Central Bank use its Transmission Protection Instrument, the tool built to stop a disorderly run in one country’s bonds from breaking the euro’s plumbing.

Jean-Claude Juncker, when he ran the European Commission, once said France was given leeway on fiscal rules “because it is France.” That political fact still sits behind the TPI debate. It does not staff a lycée. The Banque de France sees growth of 0.4% in 2026 and 0.9% in 2027, against the government’s 0.5% and 1.0%, and it puts potential growth near 1% a year. Growth will not close a primary deficit of 2.9% of GDP.

Senators take the state budget on 20 November, with a vote listed for 9 December. Every month the 10-year trades near 5% adds to the 2028 and 2029 coupons, whether or not a text finally becomes law.

Disclaimer: This article is news reporting and analysis of public finances and bond-market prices, and it is for information only. It is not investment advice, a recommendation to buy or sell any French government bond or related security, or a forecast of default. Readers who are considering a financial decision should consult a qualified investment adviser or licensed portfolio manager who can look at their own circumstances. Debt ratios, yields, budget targets and credit ratings are those published by the named official bodies and research houses at the dates given above and will change with new prints, votes and market sessions.

Harry is the editor of IAQABA, an independent publication he owns and runs. A decade in journalism, beginning as a reporter and now as the editor of his own titles, has left him with a clear test for what deserves a story: it has to change what a reader knows or decides, and it has to rest on something he can point to. That rules out recycled press releases, forecasts with no data behind them and rumours that no document supports. It leaves room for a great deal, and the site covers news, business, science and technology alongside sports, entertainment and lifestyle, with travel, auto and gaming given the same standard rather than lighter treatment. Sources are primary wherever possible: the regulator's filing, the company's own statement, the transcript, the dataset, or the product on Harry's desk. Figures are checked before they are published and rechecked if a reader questions them. Mistakes are corrected under a published policy. Readers across the world can reach him directly at support@iaqaba.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending