Connect with us

NEWS

Meta Can Halve Italy’s €805 Million Camera-Roll Fine

Italy fined Meta €805 million for a default-on Facebook gallery scanner, using ePrivacy to bypass Ireland, with a path to pay half by complying.

Published

on

Italy’s privacy authority fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited €805 million, about $887 million, over a Facebook Android feature that read camera rolls without a specific yes. It is the largest sum the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali has issued. The 13 November 2026 order, announced in Rome the next day, also records a cheaper exit: comply and pay half.

The feature, live since 2023, is “Get camera roll suggestions when you’re browsing Facebook.” It surfaces photos and videos from the phone as post ideas while people scroll. Meta says it will appeal and calls the amount disproportionate. The same menu still sits in the app outside Italy.

One Android Tap Opened the Whole Camera Roll

The file began on 10 July 2025, when the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti of Bolzano, also called Verbraucherzentrale Südtirol, told the Garante that Facebook had changed the app without notice. The consumer centre said gallery-based sharing suggestions had been switched on in a tacit way. It also floated a link to Meta’s AI systems. The authority found no evidence for that claim and left AI out of this case, which Meta denies using the gallery for.

Engineers in the Garante’s digital technologies department then installed Facebook version 548.1.0.51.64 from scratch on an Android 14 phone. They pulled the AndroidManifest.xml file from the package, checked it with apksigner, and watched a first-run session. President Pasquale Stanzione sat as rapporteur when the board adopted measure 815.

WHAT THE TEST PHONE SHOWED

  • One prompt, two rights: The app asked once for “Photos and videos,” bundling READ_MEDIA_IMAGES and READ_MEDIA_VIDEO, two distinct Android permissions.
  • On before it could work: The in-app suggestions switch was preset to active, though it produced nothing until the system permission was granted.
  • A vague pre-prompt: The first attempt to make a post, story or reel said gallery access would “share photos and videos, receive suggestions on photos to upload and enable other features.”
  • Broad and lasting access: A full grant lets the app read the whole library, usually on a lasting basis, and revoke sits in device settings, not in the prompt.
  • Older phones inherited it: People already on Facebook when a handset moved to Android 13, which arrived in June 2022, could receive the newer READ_MEDIA rights automatically if the app still held READ_EXTERNAL_STORAGE.

The manifest also listed ACCESS_MEDIA_LOCATION, which covers location data in a photo’s EXIF tags. Granted in one system window, the photo right can carry location without a second ask. The technical report called that path “very likely” and could not verify it. The Garante did not rest the order on location, on uploads to Meta’s servers, or on special-category data. The case is the access itself.

Android has offered, since 2023, a photo picker that needs no permission for a single chosen image. The Garante’s engineers wrote that a one-photo post can use that picker, while a scanner that proposes content cannot, because it needs broader and continuing access. That access, they said, should have been a separate request, tied only to the feature and off by default. Meta instead fused several functions with different access needs into one ask. Meta’s own brief later admitted the feature “cannot operate on a one-photo-at-a-time basis” and that the permission applies to the app as a whole.

Why Ireland Did Not Get This Case

Meta’s first move was to send the file to Dublin. In its 14 November 2025 reply, which it described as voluntary, Meta Platforms Ireland Limited said the Irish Data Protection Commission was the lead authority under the GDPR’s one-stop shop. It also said Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which transposes the ePrivacy Directive, did not apply because the feature used no “tracking tools” and, in Meta’s telling, never left the phone.

The Garante dismissed both points. ePrivacy is enforced country by country. There is no one-stop shop, a fact Meta’s 12 October 2026 defence brief itself accepted, while still arguing that related GDPR articles belonged in Ireland. The Italian board used those GDPR articles only to define consent and information. It found a single breach of Article 122. It said it will send the order to the Irish commission for any checks that office wants to make.

The infringed provision, Article 122 of the Italian Data Protection Code, which transposes the European ePrivacy Directive, protects the smartphone as part of the individual’s private sphere; consequently, any access to the information stored on such devices requires free and informed consent, regardless of whether data is transmitted or any harm occurs.

Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, 14 November 2026 press release

That reading tracks the directive’s own recital 24, which treats a user’s terminal and the information stored on terminal equipment as part of the private sphere. Article 5(3) allows storage or access only with consent given after clear information. Harm is not an element. Transmission is not an element. Meta argued the feature ran on-device, read only basic metadata such as date and time, and sent nothing to its servers. The authority answered that Article 122 does not mention a network, that Meta’s privacy policy describes obtaining gallery data, and that encrypted traffic left the Garante unable to prove a negative Meta itself had not evidenced.

On consent, the board applied the Court of Justice line from Planet49 and Orange România: a yes given for one object cannot be stretched over another. Tapping Allow to publish a photo, after a line about “other features,” was not a specific yes to a default-on gallery scanner. Meta said it did not even use consent as its GDPR basis. It cited contract for adults and legitimate interest for minors. Under Article 122 those bases do not open the phone.

€700 Million Was Only the Starting Point

The full 13 November 2026 order walks through the European Data Protection Board’s six-step fine method. A breach of Article 122 is punished under GDPR Article 83(5), via Article 166(2) of the Italian code. The ceiling is €20 million or 4% of worldwide yearly turnover, whichever is higher. The relevant turnover is the group’s, not the Irish subsidiary’s.

Meta Platforms, Inc. reported 2025 revenue of $200,966 million in its results for the year ended 31 December 2025. At the European Central Bank reference rate that day, $1.1750 per euro, the decision converts that figure to €171,034,893,617. Four percent of that sum is about €6.84 billion. The Garante classed the breach as medium seriousness, in the lower part of the band, and set the starting amount at 10.2% of the cap, which it fixed at €700 million.

HOW THE €805 MILLION WAS BUILT

Step Amount What the decision weighed
Legal cap (4% of 2025 group turnover) About €6.84 billion Group revenue, not Italian revenue
Starting amount €700 million 10.2% of the cap, medium seriousness
After conduct factors €805 million €105 million added; still inside the 10% to 20% band
If Meta complies and pays in the appeal window €402.5 million Half under Article 166(8) of the Privacy Code

Three aggravating factors outweighed one moderate mitigator. Meta controls the app’s architecture and did not split the feature’s access request from posting. A 2019 Italian order counted, with reduced weight because of time and the older rules then in force. Cooperation counted more heavily: Meta labelled legally due answers as voluntary, misstated the in-app default in November 2025 and corrected it only in its defence, offered no technical proof for a closed system, and gave no user count. That last gap forced the authority to build its own estimate.

It started from AGCOM’s 35.6 million monthly unique Facebook users in Italy in September 2025 and a year-end figure of about 28.5 million, then applied Android’s share of Italian mobile use. The press announcement rounded the result to about 20 million Android users. Meta called that estimate unsupported and offered no alternative number. Changes after the Bolzano report, including app version 581, an April 2026 Help Center article, and later updates, counted in Meta’s favour. The board called them late and limited to people who update. The final €805 million is about 0.47% of group turnover. The Garante applied no extra deterrence multiplier.

Italian law lets a firm close this kind of case by complying with the orders and paying half the fine in the time allowed for an appeal. Half of €805 million is €402.5 million. Meta has said it will appeal, which is a different path from taking that reduction.

The Fix in Version 581 Never Reaches Holdouts

The breach is still running for people who have not updated the app and for people who already tapped Allow at the system prompt. Version 581, Meta said, stops the in-app control from looking active before any system permission is granted. Users on older builds still see the previous interface. The Garante found those patches cannot cure access that already took place. They affect only the size of the fine.

Android 14, which arrived in autumn 2023, added “Allow limited access.” The board said that option is not offered on Android 13 and earlier, that it still applies to the whole app rather than to one feature, and that every change to the selected set repeats the procedure, which in practice pushes people toward the widest grant. “For the Authority, the limited nature of the access makes no difference.”

WHAT META MUST CHANGE IN 60 DAYS

  • Separate consent: Ask for a distinct, specific yes for the feature, and explain what it does, that it reaches the gallery, and how to turn it off.
  • Default off: Keep the feature disabled by default, including for people who already granted the system permission.
  • No silent reactivation: If the deadline passes without compliance, the feature may not be turned on for anyone who has not given valid consent.
  • Two reports: Tell the Garante what work has started within 30 days of notification, and what measures are in place within 90 days.

The clocks run from notification of the order, not from the press date. Payment of the fine is also due within 60 days of notification unless Meta uses the half-pay route or a court suspends it.

THE FILE FROM BOLZANO TO ROME

  1. 10 July 2025: The Bolzano consumer centre files its report against Meta Platforms Ireland Ltd.
  2. 27 October 2025: The Garante asks for information under Article 122.
  3. 14 November 2025: Meta replies, disputes competence, copies the Irish commission “as a courtesy.”
  4. 18 May 2026: The technical report on the Android 14 test phone is delivered.
  5. 29 July 2026: Formal proceedings open. The notice briefly named the wrong Irish company; Meta Platforms Ireland Limited confirmed it was the controller and defended the case, so the board held the slip caused no prejudice.
  6. 12 October 2026: Meta files its defence, asks for dismissal, and does not request a hearing.
  7. 13 November 2026: The board adopts register measure 815. Vice president Ginevra Cerrina Feroni, board member Agostino Ghiglia and secretary general Luigi Montuori sat with Stanzione.

A Meta spokesperson said the company disagrees with the Garante’s reading of the facts and the law and called the sum disproportionate. The company said the feature is a simple tool that helps people post photos and videos, that a device permission is required before it can run, and that users can change that permission in settings at any time. It said it intends to appeal.

A 2019 Consent Order Comes Back as Weight

The 2026 decision identifies the prior mark as injunction order 134 of 14 June 2019, a €1 million fine against Facebook Ireland Ltd jointly with Facebook Italy S.r.l. That case grew out of the Thisisyourdigitallife app in the Cambridge Analytica affair. Fifty-seven people in Italy had downloaded the quiz app through Facebook login. Through friends sharing, it then took data on 214,077 Italian users who had not installed it, had not been told, and had not agreed. The 2026 board described that episode as communication of data “on the basis of a generic notice and non-specific consent, with preselected settings and no alternatives for the user.” It treated the parallel as real and the weight as slight.

Seven years apart, the pattern the Garante is punishing is the same shape: a wide yes, a thin notice, a setting that does not wait for a clear choice. The 2019 fine was calculated under the old Privacy Code. This one uses the GDPR turnover cap through Article 166, which is why a €1 million mark and an €805 million mark can sit in the same file without matching each other in scale.

The Same Menu Is Still Live Outside Italy

The order binds the Italian Android user base. Meta has not said it will change the camera-roll feature in other countries. The in-app gallery-suggestions switch is still there for people who look for it, including on copies of the app used outside Italy. Turning the scanner off takes two moves, not one: disable the suggestions item in Facebook’s settings, then open Android’s app permissions and set Photos and videos to Don’t allow, or to limited access on Android 14 if the person still posts from the camera roll. The OS permission is the lasting key; the in-app toggle does not, by itself, revoke READ_MEDIA.

The Garante also left a second product on a separate track. A newer 2026 feature that processes camera-roll content in the cloud was not part of this fine. The authority said it will look at that tool in its own inquiry. This decision did not find that photos left the phone, and it did not find that they were used to train models.

The Italian order also arrives after New Mexico’s $25 billion Facebook judgment, issued in October, over consumer-protection claims a jury counted more than 43 million times. That case is a different statute in a different country. Together they leave Meta fighting gallery design in Rome and old privacy language in a U.S. court at the same time.

For now the live Italian facts are narrower. The Garante has told Meta to put a specific yes in front of the scanner, to leave it off even for people who already tapped Allow, and to show its work in 30 and 90 days. Meta can pay €805 million, try to pay €402.5 million by complying inside the appeal window, or take the dispute to court. The permission model the board rejected still sits on phones that never took version 581, and on phones that never see an Italian consent screen at all.

Harry is the editor of IAQABA, an independent publication he owns and runs. A decade in journalism, beginning as a reporter and now as the editor of his own titles, has left him with a clear test for what deserves a story: it has to change what a reader knows or decides, and it has to rest on something he can point to. That rules out recycled press releases, forecasts with no data behind them and rumours that no document supports. It leaves room for a great deal, and the site covers news, business, science and technology alongside sports, entertainment and lifestyle, with travel, auto and gaming given the same standard rather than lighter treatment. Sources are primary wherever possible: the regulator's filing, the company's own statement, the transcript, the dataset, or the product on Harry's desk. Figures are checked before they are published and rechecked if a reader questions them. Mistakes are corrected under a published policy. Readers across the world can reach him directly at support@iaqaba.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending