NEWS
France’s Gigabyte Tax Puts a Meter on Free Software
France’s 11-10 gigabyte tax would bill senders €0.055 per GB, including a French nonprofit, and send the cash to the Treasury rather than the networks.
France’s National Assembly adopted a tax of €0.055 on every gigabyte that content companies send to French internet users, passing it 11 votes to 10 on 30 October. The clause is an amendment to the 2027 budget, not a finished statute, and internet providers would count the traffic while the senders paid the Treasury.
VideoLAN, the French nonprofit that ships the VLC player for free, says the same meter would cost it more than €1 million a year. The formula was aimed at Google, Meta, Amazon, Netflix and Akamai. It does not ask whether the sender sells ads, charges a subscription, or runs on donations.
Eleven Votes in a Near-Empty Chamber
The sitting opened around 9 a.m. on Friday 30 October. Of 577 deputies, 35 took part. Twenty-one of them voted yes or no, and 11 was the majority of those expressed ballots, so the clause slipped in by a single vote, with 14 abstentions.
Laurent Lhardit, a Socialist deputy from Bouches-du-Rhône, tabled the text with his group after the finance committee had already thrown out the same idea in early October. Public accounts minister David Amiel spoke against it in the chamber. So did Philippe Juvin, the committee’s general rapporteur. The National Rally members who were there abstained.
HOW 35 DEPUTIES DECIDED THE CLAUSE
| Side | Votes | Who was recorded |
|---|---|---|
| For | 11 | 5 Socialists, 2 La France Insoumise, 2 Ecologists, 2 GDR |
| Against | 10 | 5 Droite Républicaine, 4 Ensemble, 1 Democrat |
| Abstention | 14 | 10 National Rally, 4 La France Insoumise |
The public vote 9336 on 30 October is the official record, and it already carries a correction from Éric Coquerel, who chairs the finance committee. He later said two La France Insoumise members hit the wrong button on a rapid run of digital-tax amendments, and he asked for his own vote to be logged as against. Abdelkader Lahmar asked to be counted as a voluntary abstention. Those notes do not rewrite the adopted tally. They do show how thin the mandate is.
What the Per-Gigabyte Levy Would Charge
Senders would pay €0.055 for each gigabyte delivered to a French internet subscriber. A 100 GB file would cost its sender €5.50 before any cap. Users would not see a per-gigabyte line on a home bill, and Orange, SFR, Bouygues Telecom and Free would not be the taxpayers. They would be the counters.
Lhardit’s group published amendment I-1358 of the budget on 9 October and wrote it as new articles 302 bis ZP to 302 bis ZS of the general tax code, under the title “Taxe sur les producteurs de données numériques.” The Socialist draft over the summer had priced the same idea at €0.10 a gigabyte. The adopted rate is €0.055.
The bill is capped at 15% of a company’s turnover in France, or 2% of its total turnover, whichever ceiling applies. Groups with no French subsidiary would still owe the tax. The authors say the take could reach €10 billion a year. They rest that figure on 200 billion gigabytes a year reaching French subscribers, a volume they attribute to Arcep. Multiply that volume by €0.055 and the uncapped product is €11 billion, before the 15% and 2% lids. Amiel put the realistic yield nearer €5 billion and warned that about half of it could fall on smaller providers, including French ones.
THE BILL AT €0.055 A GIGABYTE
| Volume | Tax before the caps | Whose figure |
|---|---|---|
| 100 GB file | €5.50 | Rate in the amendment |
| 200 billion GB a year | €11 billion | Authors’ Arcep citation times the rate |
| Expected annual take | €10 billion | Socialist authors |
| Minister’s working take | About €5 billion | David Amiel |
Juvin told the chamber the big platforms could push the cost onto advertisers. Lhardit answered that he could not see how a tax lands on people who use Facebook, Instagram or TikTok, because those services are free.
I fail to see how a tax can be passed on to users of Facebook, Instagram or TikTok, since these services are free.
Laurent Lhardit, Socialist deputy, after the 30 October vote
Free apps still move video, images and ads by the gigabyte. Advertisers pay for that inventory, and a higher cost of delivery is one more line in the media-buying sheet, which is the path Juvin was pointing at.
A French Nonprofit Gets the Same Meter as Netflix
VideoLAN posted within hours of the vote. The group said the tax, as written, would cost it more than €1 million a year, a figure that at €0.055 a gigabyte implies about 18.2 million gigabytes of downloads and updates toward French users. Each installer and each security patch would count. The amendment names no floor and no carve-out for associations or free software.
So, the French socialists, and Parliament members just voted a tax, that they don’t understand, which would cost VideoLAN more than 1 million euro per year.
They are probably the most clueless politician on Earth? And they claim they want technological sovereignty…… https://t.co/JX7tW6iJrP
— VideoLAN (@videolan) October 30, 2026
Lhardit replied that the 15% and 2% caps would protect VideoLAN. A cap tied to turnover is a thin shield for a nonprofit that, in its own follow-up, said it has almost no money and gives the software away. If French revenue is near zero, 15% of near zero is near zero, unless the tax office treats donations, app-store pass-throughs, or foreign grants as turnover. The text does not settle that. It also does not say the project is exempt.
A volume tax that cannot see the difference between a paid stream and a free player will bill both. The obvious reply from a project that lives on downloads is to stop answering requests from French addresses, which is a poor way to pursue the “technological sovereignty” Lhardit’s group put in the sales pitch.
Klaba Counts 500 Gigabits Toward French ISPs
Octave Klaba founded OVHcloud, a French host that sends a lot of data toward French access networks because French clients host sites, backups and video there. He published a worksheet on 31 October. Toward French ISPs, he put OVHcloud at about 500 Gbps at the 95th percentile and about 324 Gbps on average. On that traffic, he said the gross tax would reach €70 million a year, then fall somewhere between €23 million and €70 million once the 15% and 2% caps are applied, money he said the company would have to collect for the state and pass on to customers.
Xavier Niel, who founded Free, needed one sentence on 31 October: “Ce sont des ignares incompétents.” Free would be one of the access providers told to build the meter, and it is also the operator that sells unlimited mobile data, so a tax on every gigabyte leaving a content sender is not an abstract file for that group.
Klaba’s point is the unit price. Wholesale bandwidth is sold in cents, sometimes fractions of a cent, per gigabyte of transit. A tax of €0.055 on the same gigabyte is many times the transport. A French host that serves French users from French halls would pay it on the way out. A foreign platform that parks copies on a global content network would pay it too, but it has more room to shift caches, compress harder, or raise prices in one country. That is the distortion he flagged, and it is the opposite of a levy that only nicks California.
The Money Would Go to the Treasury
European access companies have spent years asking Brussels for a “fair share” from the platforms that fill the pipes. This French text borrows the grievance and then routes the cash to general revenue. Nothing in the amendment earmarks a euro for fiber, 5G, or rural upgrades. Orange does not get a cheque. The state does.
The authors say five companies already dominate the inbound mix, and they name Google, Meta, Amazon, Netflix and Akamai as about half the traffic Arcep sees. The regulator’s own 16 July 2026 note on the state of the internet is more precise: at the interconnection points of the main French ISPs, inbound traffic reached 56 Tbit/s at the end of 2025, up 10.4% on 2024, and Akamai plus Netflix, Amazon, Google and Meta together made up 49 percent of traffic to users. Outbound traffic grew faster, up 28.1% to 6.6 Tbit/s, which narrowed the usual download-heavy gap but did not change who fills the inbound half.
A tax on that inbound half is easy to sell as a Google bill. It is harder to sell once the other 51% is in view, because that remainder is every other sender the ISPs can identify: French publishers, game stores, cloud regions, software mirrors, university dumps, and a media player that refuses ads. Amiel’s warning that about half the money could come from smaller, including French, providers is the budget office saying the same thing with a yield attached.
Who Holds the Traffic Counter
The access providers would build, under Arcep and the public-finances directorate, a consolidated and anonymised count of data toward their customers, with the sender identified and with no record of the content or the destination. Totals would go to the tax office every quarter. Amiel told the chamber the scheme would need traffic sensors on the networks, or measurements on users’ devices, which is a larger machine than a quarterly spreadsheet.
WHAT ACCESS PROVIDERS WOULD HAVE TO DO
- The count: Measure volumes toward their own subscribers and tag each sender, without logging what the bits contain or where they go.
- The filing: Hand the consolidated totals to the tax authorities every quarter, under Arcep and the DGFiP.
- The gap: The amendment leaves the technical methods, the audit trail, and the appeal route for a sender who disputes its volume to a later decree.
A tax whose base is measured by a third party, on a payer who does not hold the logs, will produce disputes the moment the first bill lands. CDNs make that worse, because a film “from Netflix” may leave a cache that is legally a different company. The political pitch was a simple per-gigabyte sticker. The collection design is a census of the open internet, run by four French ISPs, for Bercy.
The 3 November Vote Can Wipe the Tax Out
Nothing in the 30 October tally puts €0.055 on a working invoice. The clause lives inside the first part of finance bill no. 3210, the revenue chapter of the 2027 budget, and that chapter still has to be voted as a block.
THE PATH STILL AHEAD
- Early October 2026: The finance committee rejects the same per-gigabyte device.
- 9 October 2026: Lhardit and the Socialist group table amendment I-1358 for the public sitting.
- 30 October 2026: The Assembly adopts it, 11 votes to 10, with 35 deputies taking part.
- 3 November 2026: Deputies vote on the whole revenue section; if that section falls, the gigabyte clause falls with it.
Coquerel, in his 31 October note, said the amendment would have no effect because the budget itself would be rejected. That is a political forecast, not a legal fact, and the 3 November sitting is where it gets tested. If the revenue chapter survives, the Senate still has to examine the bill, and the government, which opposed the tax in the chamber, can still try to strip it in a second deliberation. Until one of those steps kills it, the live text is a meter on every identified sender, written by 11 deputies, with a French nonprofit already running the arithmetic on a free player.
-
BUSINESS5 months agoAramco Crash Kills 14 Two Days After Oil Restart
-
NEWS6 months agoSalah Captained Egypt to Their First World Cup Win
-
GAMING2 months agoZelda’s 40th Switch 2 Ships Without a Zelda Game
-
NEWS3 months agoApple Labor Day Deals Hide June’s Memory Price Hike
-
NEWS4 months agoEl Niño Puts Israel’s Needed Winter Rain on a Flood Clock
-
GAMING2 months agoPalworld 1.0.4 Adds Palpedia Search After the 1.0 Launch
-
NEWS4 months agoSaudi Visa Routes Split Nigerian Travelers Into Two Speeds
-
BUSINESS9 months agoBAE’s 60-Year Saudi Franchise Now Runs Through Taif
