Connect with us

SCIENCE

Grand Canyon Egyptian Cave Hoax: The 1909 Arizona Gazette Story

The Grand Canyon Egyptian cave hoax is the April 5, 1909 Arizona Gazette story. A Flagstaff paper named the formula eleven days later, and no cave was found.

Published

on

If a video told you the Smithsonian found an Egyptian city in the Grand Canyon, you are hearing a newspaper story, not a dig report. The Grand Canyon Egyptian cave hoax is that story: a front page in a Phoenix paper that named a cliff cave, two explorers, and a shipment of relics. No archive has matched the cave, the men, or the relics.

You can sort the claim without a river trip. The sections below quote what the front page described, set it beside an empty Smithsonian file search, and separate the canyon’s Egyptian place names from the cavern in the tale.

What Did the April 5 Article Claim?

On April 5, 1909, the Arizona Gazette of Phoenix led its front page with “EXPLORATIONS IN GRAND CANYON.” Smaller lines promised an immense cavern, an enthused Professor Jordan, and finds that pointed to an ancient people who had migrated from the Orient. An unnamed writer said G. E. Kinkaid had come through the city the day before with news of a cliff citadel found on a solo boat trip, and that the Smithsonian Institute, as the paper spelled it, was paying for the work.

A Boat Story Printed on March 12

The cave did not show up unannounced. On March 12 the same paper ran a short item, “G. E. KINCAID REACHES YUMA,” and that earlier spelling, with a c, is the first crack in the account. The item never mentions Egypt, mummies, or a cavern.

  • Kincaid of Lewiston, Idaho, had left Green River, Wyoming, in October and boated alone to Yuma.
  • The item called him the second man to make that full run, and it had him lose only an oar in the sluiceways at Laguna Dam.
  • He carried a camera and claimed more than 700 views of the river and the canyons.
  • It said some interesting archaeological discoveries were unearthed, then stopped, with a promise of another trip the next winter.

Laguna Dam was the local news that week, so a boatman who had shot the sluiceways fit the paper. The March 12 item reads as a setup, and the larger tale arrived on April 5 with the name respelled Kinkaid.

The Cavern’s Own Measurements

Kinkaid’s quoted report puts the mouth on the east wall, above a shelf that hid it from the river. Before the cups and the idols, the paper tries to sound surveyed. The entrance, he says, is 1,486 feet down the sheer canyon wall.

What the April 5 piece states What it prints Why it fails a check
How deep the passage sits About 1,480 feet below the surface, and also “nearly a mile underground” A mile is 5,280 feet, so the two descriptions in that sentence do not match
How high the mouth sits About 2,000 feet above the river The piece uses this height to put an ancient river at the cave
Where to start looking 42 miles upriver from El Tovar Crystal Canyon That canyon name is not a Grand Canyon place
How far the side passages go 854 feet and 634 feet No survey notes exist to match either length

The depth line fails on its own terms, and the direction line leaves a hiker with nowhere to stand. Stains about 2,000 feet above the river bed mark the mouth, while steps of some thirty yards run down to where the river supposedly flowed when people lived there. The story needs the Colorado to have once run along that shelf.

An Idol, a Crypt, and a Line About Tribes

The finds mix traditions the way a yarn does. A cross-legged idol holds a lotus in each hand and “almost resembles Buddha,” and the writer says the worship “most resembles the ancient people of Tibet.” Earlier in the same article the builders are “possibly from Egypt, tracing back to Ramses.” Copper tools “hard as steel,” a gray metal that “resembles platinum,” and stones carved with “the head of the Malay type” all sit in that shrine.

The crypt is the part later posts lift out and call Egyptian. Mummies lie on separate hewn shelves, each one male in the paper’s count, some covered with clay and all wrapped in a bark fabric, with copper cups and pieces of broken swords at the head. Upwards of 50,000 people, the piece says, could have lived in the caverns comfortably. One bare room is called a dining hall because cooking utensils were found in it.

The article then offers a theory that still does harm. It says the Indian tribes of Arizona are “descendants of the serfs or slaves” of the cave people. It also attaches a Hopi emergence tale, credited to the artist W. E. Rollins, about ancestors climbing out of an underworld in the canyon. That is the paper’s version, placed there to give the citadel a local root. It is not a tribal statement that Egyptian mummies were found in 1909.

Kinkaid, Jordan, and the Missing File

The two names are the next place the story breaks. Kinkaid is called “the first white child born in Idaho” and a Smithsonian scout for thirty years. No record of that man has turned up, not as an Idaho first, not as a river runner, and not on a Smithsonian roster. The March 12 spelling and the April 5 spelling are the only contemporary traces, and neither item carries a reporter’s byline.

Professor S. A. Jordan is the other blank. The famous Jordan of that year was David Starr Jordan, president of Stanford, a naturalist tied to the Smithsonian since the mid-1870s. In 1906 he was offered the Institution’s directorship and stayed at Stanford after the San Francisco earthquake wrecked the campus. His initials are not S. A. The Gazette’s professor shares a surname with a man readers already trusted, which is a useful trick if you want a science story to sound staffed.

A written reply from the Department of Anthropology in 2000 names an empty search: no Professor Jordan, no Kincaid, and no lost Egyptian civilization in Arizona. The note adds that the story keeps turning up in books and articles anyway. One tell sits in the paper’s own wording. A scout of thirty years would know the employer’s name. The Gazette says Smithsonian Institute, over and over, and the real name is Smithsonian Institution.

Kinkaid’s quote also explains, inside the original story, why a visitor will never be allowed to check. The entrance is on government land, a visitor will be turned away “under penalty of trespass,” and the scientists wish to work “unmolested.” The keep-away rule is a paragraph in the hoax, written so an empty trail would look like orders.

Why Did Flagstaff Call It a Mulhatton Story?

A false pair of names still leaves the question of who wrote the page, and Flagstaff answered while the story was new. Of more than a dozen Arizona papers checked for a historical study of the episode, only the Jerome Mining News reprinted the Gazette piece, and that reprint added no reporting. On April 16, 1909, the Coconino Sun put a short item on the front page under the headline “Looks Like a Mulhatton Story.” The writer called the underground city a work of imagination, noted that people at the canyon would have heard of a real dig, and said the entrance had been parked on a sheer wall “where no one but a person with a great imagination could reach it.”

Joseph Mulhattan, spelled Mulhatton in that headline, was a hardware drummer whose side work was planting wild stories in newspapers. He made no money from the tales, and papers ran them because they drew readers, which is the picture in the Museum of Hoaxes record of his career. In an 1883 interview he called the hoaxes “little novels.” Variant spellings of his name were already common in his lifetime.

His signature was a cave full of Egyptian-looking dead. On June 22, 1878, the Cincinnati Commercial carried his Grand Crystal Cave under Glasgow Junction, Kentucky, explored for twenty-three miles, with mummies that “present every appearance of the Egyptian mummies.” The Louisville Courier-Journal called that piece a hoax the next day, and papers across the country reprinted it anyway.

On December 12, 1881, a report in the Chicago Inter-Ocean about a cave at Litchfield, Kentucky, added an Egyptian pyramid, hieroglyphs, and a visit from “Joseph Mulhattan, geologist and scientist.” The mummies were again almost Egyptian, and the writing on the walls was again a mystery. He did not have to say the word Egypt outright. The hint did the work.

Set beside those older tales in Don Lago’s 2009 essay in The Ol’ Pioneer, the Gazette piece repeats the habits: bodies only “possibly” from Egypt, mystery marks on the walls, shelves instead of a simple ledge, copper vessels, and a grand name with “Crystal” in it. “El Tovar Crystal Canyon” pairs the El Tovar Hotel on the rim, which the Santa Fe Railway was advertising heavily, with Mulhattan’s Grand Crystal Cave. Lago does not claim a signed confession. The author is either Mulhattan or a writer copying a formula western editors already knew by name.

He was already an Arizona character by 1909. He left the drummer’s route for prospecting in the state in 1893, and he spent a few months in the state asylum in Phoenix in 1900. Small papers still wrote him up as a miner who would hand a newsroom a tale and smile. He died in 1913 trying to cross a flooded Gila River near Kelvin.

The Gazette was a willing host. Three days after the cave story, on April 8, it printed a joke about astronomers on Mars watching American lakes go dry. A front page in that office was not a sworn scientific record.

Egyptian Names That Predate the Article

The map is the piece that still feels like proof after the names of the explorers fail. Isis Temple, Horus Temple, the Tower of Ra, and Osiris Tower are real labels on the canyon. Haley Johnson, president of the Grand Canyon Historical Society, ties those landmark names to Clarence Dutton’s geologic survey of 1882. Dutton gave walls and summits to gods and heroes from many traditions, Egyptian, Hindu, and Arthurian among them.

The names were on maps long before the Gazette printed a word about Kinkaid. They explain why a later reader thought the map was confessing. A short Smithsonian Channel film walks through Osiris Tower and the Temple of Ra and asks where the names come from, which is the right question, and it is not a film about a lost citadel.

David Hatcher Childress, who did the most to revive the Gazette piece, wrote that he was shocked to see the Egyptian names and decided the cave had to sit among them. The names rewarded a reader who was already convinced. They were never a set of coordinates, and they do not point at a mouth 42 miles from a canyon the map does not contain.

The Gazette Story’s Second Life After 1962

Once the 1909 record is this thin, the open question is how the page became a belief. The front page was forgotten in Arizona almost at once. It came back in a 1962 reprint book, Arizona Cavalcade, a collection of old newspaper pieces, and David Hatcher Childress carried it into Lost Cities of North and Central America in 1992. He later wrote that his first reaction was to bet the cave “was fabricated by the author of that book” because it “sounds phony.” Finding the original Gazette page changed his mind: “There it was in black and white.”

A printed clipping still needs a place and a workforce. Childress called the stretch of canyon with Egyptian and Hindu names “a forbidden zone” where no one was allowed. That line, added to Kinkaid’s trespass warning, is the seed of later claims that aircraft, gates, and rangers exist to hide a door. There was no second Gazette article, no photograph, and no member of the supposed crew who ever spoke on the record.

Later versions add what the paper left out. Some move the builders to Atlantis or to another world. Some turn the mummies into giants hauled to a secret base. Some point at a gated alcove, a restricted backcountry zone, or a helicopter and treat the restriction as the missing proof. The canyon does restrict some ground. The reason printed in 1909 was a sentence in the hoax.

Closed Caves and the Trespass Line

Belief sends people to the rim, and the rim has real caves with real locks. On the park page on Grand Canyon caves, the stated policy is that all caves are closed to visitation except for research. The reasons given there are bats and other cave wildlife, water moving through the rock, mineral formations, fossil bones, and prehistoric artifacts. Unauthorized entry is illegal, and a name scratched in a cave does not heal.

Those bones and artifacts are the canyon’s own record, from extinct animals and from Native people who used the caves, not a crate of Egyptian coffins. A gate on a known cave protects that record. It does not confirm the citadel in the Gazette, and a photo of the gate does not become a doorway from 1909.

BEFORE YOU TRUST A NEW VERSION

  • The names: Kinkaid and Jordan should appear in some record besides the Gazette, and they do not.
  • The employer: The paper says Smithsonian Institute, and the real name is Smithsonian Institution.
  • The landmark: A distance measured from El Tovar Crystal Canyon cannot be hiked, because that canyon is not on the map.
  • The local test: People at the canyon in April 1909 would have known about a dig of that size, and the Flagstaff paper said they did not.

A post that fails those checks is repeating the Gazette, whatever new aircraft or doorway it adds. Mulhattan’s Kentucky cave grew longer and richer each time a paper picked it up, and this tale has picked up giants and patrols in the same way.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did Kinkaid Ship Relics to Washington?

The April 5 piece says he did. In the long quotation, Kinkaid carries relics down the Colorado to Yuma and ships them to Washington with details of the discovery. No accession, letter, or crate tied to that shipment has surfaced. A shipment of that kind would leave a receiving record, and the Department of Anthropology’s 2000 search found no file to attach it to.

Did Joseph Mulhattan Admit Writing the Gazette Piece?

No admission has turned up. Arizona papers of his lifetime treated a visit from him as a scoop in itself, because he would walk into a small office and hand over a tale. The April 5 piece follows the old cave habits so closely that Flagstaff’s word “Mulhattonized” fit even if a Gazette writer held the pen.

Why Do New Versions Add Helicopters and Giants?

Helicopters and giant bodies are not in the 1909 paper. The paper’s keep-out line is Kinkaid’s trespass warning, which later tellers turn into patrols and a sealed door. Giant mummies, including a radio claim in early 2008 of bodies 12 to 14 feet tall removed to a secret base, belong to that later layer. The Gazette’s mummies are adult men on shelves, wrapped in bark fabric, with no height given.

What Should You Ask About a Photo of the Entrance?

Ask for the photographer, the date, and a point you can find on a Grand Canyon map. The pictures the Gazette bragged about, a flashlight view of one mummy and a camera full of river scenes, have never surfaced in an archive. A new photo of a shadowed alcove, or of a cave the park has gated, shows the canyon as it is. It does not show the citadel.

Was the Paper Called the Phoenix Gazette?

The masthead on the April 5, 1909 piece is the Arizona Gazette, published in Phoenix. Later posts say the Phoenix Gazette. The city is right, and the title is wrong, which is what happens when a story is copied from a summary instead of from the page.

Flagstaff’s test still works on a new post. Someone besides the anonymous writer has to have handled the relics, and those relics have to be somewhere a second person can see. The April 5 page has never met either condition.

Harry is the editor of IAQABA, an independent publication he owns and runs. A decade in journalism, beginning as a reporter and now as the editor of his own titles, has left him with a clear test for what deserves a story: it has to change what a reader knows or decides, and it has to rest on something he can point to. That rules out recycled press releases, forecasts with no data behind them and rumours that no document supports. It leaves room for a great deal, and the site covers news, business, science and technology alongside sports, entertainment and lifestyle, with travel, auto and gaming given the same standard rather than lighter treatment. Sources are primary wherever possible: the regulator's filing, the company's own statement, the transcript, the dataset, or the product on Harry's desk. Figures are checked before they are published and rechecked if a reader questions them. Mistakes are corrected under a published policy. Readers across the world can reach him directly at support@iaqaba.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending