Is it possible for any company to be successful? A Reddit user sparks a debate


A Reddit user posted a question on the r/business subreddit, asking whether it is possible for any company to be successful. The user, who goes by the name of 259felix, argued that the value of business knowledge and strategies diminishes as more companies learn and adopt them, creating a zero-sum game where one company’s gain is another company’s loss. The post received mixed responses from other Reddit users, some of whom agreed with the premise, while others challenged it with counterexamples and alternative perspectives.

What is the value of business knowledge and strategies?

259felix claimed that business knowledge and strategies, such as differentiation, positioning, and innovation, have value only until other companies learn about them and copy them. The user compared business to chemistry, where the more people know about a subject, the better it is for the advancement of science and society. In contrast, the user suggested that business is a competitive field where the more people know about a subject, the worse it is for the profitability and sustainability of companies.

Is it possible for any company to be successful? A Reddit user sparks a debate
Is it possible for any company to be successful? A Reddit user sparks a debate

The user also cited the example of consultants, who help companies gain a competitive advantage by providing them with specialized knowledge and advice. However, the user questioned the effectiveness of this approach, as consultants often work with multiple companies in the same industry, potentially sharing the same insights and recommendations with different clients. The user concluded that consultants are essentially helping one company at the expense of another.

How did other Reddit users respond to the question?

The question sparked a lively debate among other Reddit users, who offered various opinions and arguments on the topic. Some of the main points raised by different users were:

  • Not every company can be successful: Some users agreed with 259felix’s view that not every company can be successful, as there are limited resources and customers in the market. They pointed out that some industries are more competitive and saturated than others, making it harder for new entrants or existing players to survive and thrive. They also noted that some companies fail due to poor management, lack of innovation, or external factors beyond their control.
  • Every company can be successful: Some users disagreed with 259felix’s view that not every company can be successful, as they believed that there are always opportunities and niches for companies to exploit and create value. They argued that business knowledge and strategies are not static or finite, but dynamic and evolving, as companies constantly learn from their competitors, customers, and environment. They also suggested that success is relative and subjective, depending on how each company defines and measures it.
  • It depends on how you define success: Some users took a more nuanced approach to the question, as they acknowledged that success can have different meanings and dimensions for different companies. They proposed that success can be evaluated based on various criteria, such as financial performance, customer satisfaction, social impact, environmental sustainability, employee engagement, or innovation potential. They also emphasized that success is not a one-time event or a fixed state, but a continuous process or a journey that requires constant adaptation and improvement.

What are some of the factors that contribute to business success?

While there is no definitive answer to the question of whether every company can be successful, there are some common factors that have been identified by researchers and practitioners as contributing to business success. Some of these factors are:

  • Vision and mission: A clear and compelling vision and mission can help a company define its purpose, direction, and goals. A vision articulates what a company wants to achieve in the long term, while a mission describes how a company intends to achieve its vision in the short term. A vision and mission can also help a company align its actions with its values and communicate its identity and culture to its stakeholders.
  • Strategy and execution: A sound strategy and execution can help a company create and sustain a competitive advantage in the market. A strategy outlines how a company will use its resources and capabilities to achieve its objectives and meet its customers’ needs. An execution involves implementing the strategy effectively and efficiently through planning, organizing, leading, and controlling. A strategy and execution can also help a company adapt to changing conditions and overcome challenges.
  • Innovation and differentiation: A strong innovation and differentiation can help a company offer unique products or services that add value to its customers. Innovation involves creating new or improved solutions that solve existing or emerging problems or satisfy unmet or latent needs. Differentiation involves distinguishing a company’s offerings from those of its competitors based on features, benefits, quality, price, or image. Innovation and differentiation can also help a company attract new customers or retain existing ones.
  • Customer focus and satisfaction: A high customer focus and satisfaction can help a company build loyal relationships with its customers. Customer focus involves understanding who the customers are, what they want, how they behave, and how they perceive the company’s offerings. Customer satisfaction involves meeting or exceeding the customers’ expectations regarding the quality, performance, reliability, convenience, or service of the company’s offerings. Customer focus and satisfaction can also help a company generate positive word-of-mouth and referrals.
  • Employee engagement and retention: A high employee engagement and retention can help a company enhance its productivity, performance, and profitability. Employee engagement involves creating a work environment that motivates, empowers, and supports employees to perform their best and achieve their potential. Employee retention involves retaining the best talent and reducing turnover by providing employees with fair compensation, benefits, recognition, development, and career opportunities. Employee engagement and retention can also help a company foster a culture of collaboration, innovation, and excellence.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here