Two Israeli-American men, Dan Brotman and Ilan Grapel, have formed a close bond after enduring separate detentions in Lebanon and Egypt on espionage charges. Brotman, released from Lebanese custody in July 2025, reached out to Grapel, who faced similar accusations in Egypt back in 2011, creating a unique support network for their shared trauma.
Brotman’s Harrowing Detention in Lebanon
Dan Brotman, a 38-year-old dual citizen, traveled from Syria to Lebanon in July 2025 as part of a group tour. At the Masnaa border crossing, officials detained him after spotting his Israeli citizenship in records.
Authorities accused him of being an Israeli spy and held him for six days in harsh conditions. Brotman described sleeping in a filthy cell without natural light, denied food and medical care, and facing intense interrogations about his past IDF service.
He endured physical discomfort, including handcuffs that caused wrist injuries, and witnessed other detainees in distress. After diplomatic efforts involving U.S. and Israeli officials, Lebanon released him without formal charges.
Brotman, who grew up in Massachusetts and lived in Israel and South Africa, said the experience left him with PTSD. He now warns travelers about risks in certain regions.
Grapel’s 2011 Arrest in Egypt
Ilan Grapel, then 27, visited Egypt during the Arab Spring uprisings in June 2011. Egyptian security forces arrested him in Cairo, charging him with spying for Israel and inciting unrest.
Grapel, a law student with dual citizenship, worked as an intern for a non-profit aiding refugees. Officials claimed he gathered intelligence for Mossad, Israel’s intelligence agency.
He spent over four months in prison, facing interrogations and isolation. A prisoner swap in October 2011 freed him, with Israel releasing 25 Egyptian prisoners in exchange.
Grapel later returned to the U.S., where he shared his story to highlight dangers for dual nationals. His case drew attention to tensions between Israel and Egypt at the time.
How Their Paths Crossed
After his release, Brotman searched online for others with similar experiences. He found Grapel’s story and emailed him in August 2025, seeking advice on coping with the aftermath.
The two connected via phone calls, discussing emotional recovery and media scrutiny. Their first in-person meeting happened in Toronto in September 2025, where they spoke at a Jewish community event.
Brotman credits Grapel for helping him process the trauma. Grapel advised preparing clear explanations of the events to avoid misunderstandings.
This bond has grown into a small support group, offering mutual understanding that family and friends might not fully grasp.
- Shared challenges: Both faced false spy accusations due to their Israeli ties.
- Emotional impact: Discussions focus on PTSD symptoms and rebuilding trust in travel.
- Future plans: They aim to raise awareness for other dual citizens at risk.
Lessons from Their Experiences
Brotman and Grapel emphasize caution for Israeli passport holders in Arab countries. Many nations restrict entry for those with Israeli connections, leading to sudden detentions.
Experts note rising incidents amid regional conflicts, like the ongoing Israel-Lebanon tensions in 2025. U.S. State Department advisories warn of arbitrary arrests in such areas.
Their stories highlight diplomatic challenges for dual citizens. Interventions from governments often speed releases, but not always.
| Aspect | Dan Brotman’s Case (2025) | Ilan Grapel’s Case (2011) |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Lebanon | Egypt |
| Duration | 6 days | Over 4 months |
| Accusations | Espionage, IDF links | Spying for Israel, inciting unrest |
| Release Method | Diplomatic pressure | Prisoner swap |
| Aftermath | PTSD, public speaking | Advocacy for travelers |
Broader Impact on Travelers
These cases reflect wider issues for Israeli-Americans abroad. In 2025, reports show increased scrutiny at borders due to geopolitical strains.
Brotman now runs an educational travel company and uses his experience to educate others. Grapel pursues legal work, focusing on human rights.
Their bond inspires resilience, showing how personal ordeals can lead to positive connections. As tensions persist in the Middle East, such stories remind travelers to check advisories.
We encourage readers to share this article if it resonates and comment below with your thoughts on travel safety for dual citizens.
